AliPhosCool: Stabilization


Abstract

AliPhosCool is cooling system for CERN ALICE PHOS detector.
This document describe stabilization algorithm, principles and notes about how to choose parameters.


Content

ALICE PHOS Logo

Temperature stabilization principles

Operator set

PHOS stabilization algorithm

Stabilization algorithm (see picture) uses feedback temperature sensor T1, located at cooling liquid output. When temperature became higher then Tstab+Delta, NbMax compressors switches ON. When temperature became lower then Tstab-Delta, NbMin compressors switches ON. When temperature is inside (Tstab-Delta, Tstab+Delta) range, then compressor number is not changes.

This method of stabilization have no aim to guarantee contant value of cooling liquid temperature. The aim of stabilization algorithm is to have stable AVERAGE value of temperature. To be more accurate, this algorithm gives stable value of average (over control cycle) temperature Taver. This is convenient method because PWO matrix is very massive and smooth all fast variations of temperature with greate efficiency.

goto Content


How to choose parameters of stabilization

In Oct/Nov 2009 session for 3 PHOS modules used next parameters,
which can be taken as reference point or as first estimation to choose parameters:
PHOS stabilization parameters
Final choice of parameters was Tstab=-29.4±0.6°C.

Keep in mind that Tstab is wanted cooling liquid temperature, not PWO temperature. PWO temperature will be some higher then Tstab, because of FEE heat. For example, Tstab should be about -29.5°C to achieve -25°C inside PWO matrix.

Also Note that Tstab is independent parameter, while Delta, NbMin, NbMax – chosen empirically, to have stable control cycle. It is recommended to choose Delta, NbMin, NbMax by next empirical criteria’s:

  1. Control cycle is periodic and stable.
  2. Cycle period is not less then 2 minutes (5…10 recommended).
  3. Deviation of control cycle period not more then 10…20% of average cycle period, i.e. cycle period stable enough.
  4. Average (over control cycle period) cooling liquid temperature is stable enough, i.e. deviation not more ±0.1°C.
  5. NbMax-NbMin should be 1 or 2. Choose NbMax-NbMin=1 if fractional part of average compressor number (over cycle) is inside [0.25,0.75] range or if NbMax=4. Choose NbMax-NbMin=2 if fractional part of average compressor number (over cycle) is outside [0.25,0.75] range.
There is example of stable (left) and unstable (right) control cycle.
Stable cycle Unstable cycle

goto Content


AliPhosCool Alice Phos Cooling system CERN ALICE PHOS + VNIIEF 2009 Geneve,Switzerland + Sarov,Russia Alexei.Kuryakin@cern.ch